
This card looks terrible, but after playing with it I'd say it's okay in its faction. It's a card that has a few possibilities.
1) You're fighting rats and this is in hand. You kill them without risk and set it up for a 2-damage attack later!
2) You have no weapon, you have this in hand, and you're fighting a 3-hp enemy. You can kill them in 2 hits!
3) You have a baseball bat, you have this in hand, and you're fighting an odd-hp enemy. Use this for that last hitpoint, getting it into the discard and not endangering your bat!
4) You have a baseball bat and you're fighting almost anything and this is in the discard. If your bat breaks, you have a 2-damage backup!
I never had a game where this just sat in hand in my baseball bat survivor. Somehow I always ended up in a situation where it was good. I think that this card may be like Taunt, in that it looks terrible but in practice is actually pretty good a couple times a game.